1. Volkswagen Group: All-in on Electrification, but the Road Is Rough
Volkswagen Group is the earliest and most resolute traditional automaker to shift to electrification. In Q1 2025, Volkswagen Group's global BEV sales reached 218,000 units, up 21% YoY, accounting for 9.5% of the group's total sales. In the European market, Volkswagen's EV share reached 15.2%, second only to Tesla.
ID series: The ID.4/ID.5, ID.3, and ID.Buzz are the mainly models. The ID.2all (entry-level BEV, €25,000) is expected to launch by the end of 2025, seen as Volkswagen's key weapon against Chinese brands' low-cost EVs.
PPE platform: The Premium Platform Electric co-developed with Audi. The Porsche Macan Electric and Audi Q6 e-tron are already on the market, supporting 800V and 270kW charging.
SSP platform: The Scalable Systems Platform, planned for 2026, will integrate the MEB, PPE, and J1 platforms - the core of Volkswagen's next-generation electrification.
Partnership with Xpeng: The first model has been revealed, based on Xpeng's G9 platform with Volkswagen badge, launching in 2026. This is Volkswagen's strategic move to make up for its intelligence Shortcomings.
Software predicament: The CARIAD software division was once Volkswagen's biggest Achilles' heel. Early ID series vehicles suffered from laggy infotainment, black screens, and OTA failures, severely damaging user experience. After large-scale layoffs and restructuring in 2023, CARIAD delivered a new software 2.0 in Q1 2025, with word of mouth improving, though still lagging behind Tesla and Huawei.
2. Toyota: The hold fast of a Multi-Pathway Strategy
While nearly all competitors went all-in on BEVs, Toyota adhered to a "multi-pathway strategy" - developing BEVs, hybrids, plug-in hybrids, and hydrogen fuel cells in parallel. This strategy has shown unique resilience in 2025.
Sales structure: In Q1 2025, Toyota sold 2.56 million vehicles globally, with BEVs accounting for only 3.2% (approx. 82,000 units). However, hybrids (HEVs) accounted for 36%, and plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) for 4%. This means Toyota is still selling a large number of electrified vehicles (43.2% combined), just with hybrids mainly and BEVs as a supplement.
bZ series: BEV models including the bZ4X and bZ3 have performed modestly, with only 56,000 units sold globally in Q1 2025. Toyota acknowledges lagging behind Chinese brands and Tesla in the BEV space.
Solid-state batteries: As previously noted, Toyota leads in solid-state battery technology, with plans for small-scale installation by 2027. This is Toyota's hope for a "corner overtaking" in the BEV field.
Hydrogen persistence: Cumulative sales of the Toyota Mirai second generation are only 37,000 units since its 2020 launch, far below expectations. But Toyota continues to advance hydrogen fuel cell applications in commercial vehicles and stationary power generation, forming a hydrogen alliance with Isuzu, Hino, Subaru, and others.
China market predicament: Toyota faces its most difficult situation in China. Toyota China sales fell 18% YoY in Q1 2025, with BEV models barely selling. Capacity utilization at FAW Toyota and GAC Toyota has fallen below 60%. Toyota is co-developing China-market BEVs with its Chinese partners (BYD, GAC).
3. Ford: Focus on Strengths, Cut Losses
Ford has adopted a strategy different from both Volkswagen and Toyota: focus on areas of strength and decisively exit unprofitable businesses.
Stopping losses: Ford stopped selling low-profit small BEVs in North America (e.g., the Fusion EV plan) in 2024 and postponed some large BEV SUV projects.
Commercial vehicles first: The Ford E-Transit (electric commercial van) is Ford's star product, with Q1 2025 sales up 45% YoY, holding over 60% share of the North American electric commercial van market.
Pickup stronghold: The F-150 Lightning is Ford's most successful BEV passenger vehicle, with 29,000 units sold in the US in Q1 2025, up 32% YoY, second only to the Tesla Model Y and Model 3. Ford is increasing F-150 Lightning production capacity from 150,000 to 200,000 units annually.
Technology partnerships: Ford shares Volkswagen's MEB platform, with its European BEV models (Explorer EV, Capri EV) based on the Volkswagen ID.4 platform. On batteries, Ford is partnering with CATL on an LFP battery plant in Michigan (technology licensing model), expected to start production in 2026.
Lucid technology licensing: Ford has licensed electric drive system technology from Lucid Motors for future high-performance BEVs - another case of traditional automakers "learning from" new players.
4. General Motors: Ultium Platform Carries Hope
GM has invested as heavily in electrification as Volkswagen, but market performance has fallen short of expectations.
Ultium platform: GM's $35 billion Ultium platform supports a full range of EVs from crossovers to pickups to commercial vehicles. Currently available models include the Chevrolet Equinox EV, Blazer EV, Silverado EV, Cadillac Lyriq, GMC Hummer EV, and others.
Market performance: In Q1 2025, GM's US BEV sales reached 52,000 units, up 65% YoY, though from a low base. The Chevrolet Equinox EV (starting at $34,000) is the mainly one, contributing nearly half of sales.
Challenges: Ultium platform battery production has encountered bottlenecks. Production ramp-up at GM's Ultium Cells joint venture with LG Energy Solution has been slower than expected, delaying some vehicle deliveries. GM has reduced its 2025 full-year BEV production target from 500,000 to 400,000 units.
Cruise restart: Autonomous driving subsidiary Cruise suspended operations after a serious accident in 2023, resumed testing in late 2024, and restarted limited robotaxi services in Phoenix and Dallas in Q1 2025. However, Cruise's valuation has fallen from $30 billion to approximately $9 billion.
5. Common Challenges of Transformation: Organization and Culture
While technical challenges are difficult enough, organizational and cultural challenges may be even harder for traditional automakers' electrification transformation.
Challenge 1: Conflict between ICE and EV businesses. ICE vehicles remain traditional automakers' main profit source. Overly aggressive electrification could harm ICE profitability, thereby affecting the entire company's cash flow. Volkswagen, Ford, and GM have all experienced internal debates over "balancing electrification and profits."
Challenge 2: Talent structure imbalance. Traditional automakers have large numbers of engineers specialized in engines, transmissions, and chassis, but are severely lacking in electrification, intelligence, and software talent. Toyota, Volkswagen, and Ford have been large-scale hiring software engineers in recent years while conducting unavoidable layoffs in ICE teams.
Challenge 3: Excessive decision-making chains. New players (Tesla, Nio, Xpeng, Li Auto, Xiaomi) have flat organizational structures and rapid decision-making, while traditional automakers have multiple layers, long processes, and siloed departments. To address this challenge, Volkswagen, GM, and Ford have all undergone organizational restructuring, establishing independent EV business units.
A May report from Boston Consulting Group指出 that traditional automakers' electrification transformation is a high-difficulty maneuver of "changing engines while flying." The keys to success are: rapidly learning new capabilities, decisively shedding old assets, and maintaining sufficient financial buffers.
---
Summary: There is no one-size-fits-all template for traditional automakers' electrification transformation. Volkswagen went all-in but encountered software setbacks; Toyota stuck to a multi-pathway strategy but lost ground in China; Ford focused on strengths and cut losses; GM bet heavily on Ultium but faced production ramp-up issues. Each company is finding its own path. What is certain is that this "elephants turning" battle is far from over, and the competitive landscape over the next five years remains full of variables.





